Hello dear
Welcome To Amici Restaurant
Nestled in the heart of Mt. Sinai, Amici Restaurant offers a charming neighborhood dining experience that resonates with locals and visitors alike. Known for its friendly service and vibrant atmosphere, the restaurant invites patrons to indulge in a menu rich with Italian favorites. Guests rave about dishes like the sumptuous penne alla vodka and flavorful chicken marsala, alongside delightful appetizers such as fried calamari. With generous portions and a commitment to quality, Amici is perfect for families and couples seeking comfort in every bite. The inviting bar area adds a lively touch, making each visit a memorable one.
Today's Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
Tuna Tartare
Cannellini Beans & Broccoli Rabe
Amici Lobster Roll
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
About
Amici Restaurant
Welcome to the heart of Mt. Sinai, where the spirited atmosphere of Amici Restaurant invites you in for a delightful experience. Nestled at 304 NY-25A, this local gem embodies the essence of a neighborhood eatery, offering vibrant dining coupled with a warm, inviting ambiance.
As you step inside, the rustic charm embraces you. With a spacious layout that includes a lively bar, dining areas, and even a dance floor, Amici caters to all occasions—whether you're enjoying a family dinner or celebrating a special event. The friendly staff greets you with genuine smiles, setting the tone for an enjoyable meal.
Amici's menu is a treasure trove of flavors. It's no wonder that local patrons rave about their signature dishes. The vodka sauce has earned accolades, described by one satisfied diner as the best they’ve ever had. Complementing it, the fried calamari stands out, featuring a delightful twist with fried pickles and chili peppers that adds an unexpected crunch. Each plate showcases fresh, quality ingredients, ensuring that every bite is a testament to Italian culinary tradition.
Favorites like chicken marsala and chicken piccata have become go-to options for regulars, even impressing the pickiest of eaters. There’s also a generous portion of lemon Tuscan chicken that promises to leave you satisfied, echoing sentiments of deliciousness and value through rave reviews. Diners frequently compliment the restaurant's ability to deliver both quantity and quality, often leaving with delightful leftovers.
Amici Restaurant is not just about the food; it's an experience that resonates with many. Many patrons find themselves returning, not only for the delectable dishes but also for the warm ambiance and attentive service. Indeed, this is a place where new memories are made, further enriched by an extensive wine list and refreshing dessert options like lemon sorbet, providing a perfect end to your meal.
In a world where dining out should be memorable, Amici Restaurant stands out as a must-visit destination. Whether you are a local or just passing through, this establishment invites you to join their family and enjoy what they do best: excellent food, great service, and a welcoming atmosphere. Don’t wait too long; make a reservation or just drop in to discover why it's loved by so many!
For inquiries or to plan your visit, you can reach them at +1 631-473-2400.
People talk
Our Guestbook
“ It’s a great neighborhood restaurant. Good food. A little noisy because of the bar and young kids. But that’s what a neighborhood place is supposed to be. Right? ”
“ This place was very nice. The price was good and the food was good as well. Portion size is good for the price. Service here is great and everyone is super friendly!!! Vodka sauce was the best i ever had!! Fried calamari had a surprise couple of fried pickels and fried pickled chili pepers!! Everything was amazing!! ”
“ I'll keep this short for a bunch of reasons, but we've gone here for years. This is my EXTREMELY picky italian dad's go-to for chicken marsala and my hands down favorite for chicken picatta. We came on a rainy Saturday night right after Christmas with my toddler, who got the chicken fingers, which were great. The waitress was SO friendly. Seriously, you can never go wrong coming here for great food and service. ”
“ Amici was awesome. Went here with my wife for dinner. Atmosphere was nice and rustic, great cozy place to eat. Service was extremely quick and we did not even have to ask for a thing. Food was beyond fresh and delicious, best penne alla vodka I’ve ever had. The chicken was amazing and the fried calamari was great. Everything was cooked perfectly and everyone was very nice. Will definitely be going back. ”
“ Pretty easy to spot right off of 25A . Nice looking place on the outside . Good parking . Pretty spacious inside as they have a room with a dance area & a bar & then another section with dining . Lots of wine choices & for food I ordered fried calamari for my app & lemon Tuscan chicken which was a HUGE portion . I was stuffed & still had so much leftovers & for a good price too. Wanted to keep eating but I couldn’t I was so full . Pretty good dessert options . Lemon sorbet was nice & refreshing . Loved the experience, no complaints ”
“ Amazing food and very consistent the staff is always very nice and they have a great outdoor area as well ”
“ The food is good and the service is very good. There is even live music which we love. The owner is usually on property and a wonderful person. The kitchen keeps everything moving along in a reasonable time ”
“ Our favorite Italian restaurant for past 20 years! Have had almost everything on their menu and never disappointed! Food is always delicious no matter what we order. Service is excellent and staff are attentive, friendly and very accommodating. Definitely recommend to all ”